Monday, 1 April 2013

Stolen Sharpie Revolution


Editor: Joe Biel
Bibliographic Info:
Biel, Joe. (2003). Stolen sharpie revolution: a diy zine resource. Portland, OR: Microcosm Publishing.

Descriptive Summary:
Stolen Sharpie Revolution is a jam-packed guide to zine and mail art culture that also serves as a practical how-to guide on making and designing zines. Stolen Sharpie Revolution showcases the ins and outs of producing zines, selling and distributing zines, and reaching out to other zine writers. It also doesn’t shy away from some of the realities of zine culture, including predators who sometimes prey on potential victims through zines. Tons of resource lists and zines suggestions round out Stolen Sharpie Revolution.

Evaluative comments with rating:

4/5 TVs - Go outside and take this book with you
Stolen Sharpie Revolution is an invaluable resource for seasoned zinesters and neophytes just learning about zines. The writing is clear and never condescends, the step-by-step guides are straightforward and useful, and a number of different perspectives on zines and zine related culture are presented. Stolen Sharpie Revolution only falls short in that it may be a little inaccessible for those unfamiliar with underground and punk culture, it might prove a little overwhelming at first. However, once a reader delves into Stolen Sharpie Revolution and zine culture, this will serve as a lifesaver over and over again.
Suggested Audience (age range): 13+

Readers’ advisory notes:

Appeal factors: Inspirational, offbeat, reflective, candid, richly-detailed

Readalikes: Evasion, Cometbus, Maximumrocknroll, Broken Pencil, Zine-O-File, Ghost Pine - Jeff Miller
Booktalking hook:

From the intro:

Somehow Sharpies exchange hands over and over and I'd like to think that's a good thing. I think ideas are meant to be like that, shared and passed on so that everyone can appreciate them. That is what this zine is about, creative exchange. Not to show you how things must be done but to give you a jumping off point and a few hints to do things your own way.
Reason for inclusion:
Familiarity with the publishing company and their prior works.

Category: Magazine/Zine/Zines

Broken Pencil magazine

 
Title: Broken Pencil
Editor:  Lindsay Gibb
Bibliographic Info:
Gibb, Lindsay. (2013). Broken pencil, 1 (58).
Descriptive Summary:
Broken Pencil’s primary focus is on zine culture, but it also covers independent arts, culture and music. This issue of Broken Pencil has a strong LGBTQ focus, but also includes the regular comics, guides, reviews of zines, books, comics, graphic novels and music, as well as short stories exclusive to Broken Pencil.
Evaluative comments with rating:
4/5 – Worth turning off your TV for.
There is no better document of zine culture in North America. Broken Pencil covers the margins and then some. The magazine is incredibly inclusive and no subculture should feel overlooked. This is a great accessible magazine that really attempts to great cross-country links between regional art and culture scenes. It attempts to showcase the best in underground culture while at the same time shining a spotlight on artists and projects that may as well exist in the fringes if it wasn't for Broken Pencil. It's a great guide for arts oriented teens who wondering what's happening in the rest of the country.

Suggested Audience (age range): 14+ Mildly offensive language and some mature themes

Readers’ advisory notes:
Appeal factors: Thoughtful, richly detailed, engaging, descriptive

Readalikes: Maximumrocknroll, Shameless, Bitch, Quill & Quire, Razorcake
Booktalking hook:

From page 33 Zine Philosophy: "What interests me about zines is that they carry an aura unlike anything else. it's impossible to grab a zine and not feel like you can make one too. They look easy. They look personal. And their significance is double: they deliver content and a quiet call to the reader to make their own."

Reason for inclusion:
Familiarity with the magazine and its publisher.

Category: Magazine/LGBTQ/Zines

Welcome to Tranquility



Author: Gail Simone
Bibliographic Info:
Simone, Gail. (2008). Welcome to Tranquility. La Jolla, CA: Wildstorm Productions.

Descriptive Summary:
What happens when old superheroes get put out to pasture? Apparently they retire to Tranquility. Tranquility is a city whose citizenry is made up of superheroes with their glory days behind them, their often superpowered descendents, their former enemies, and the non-powered law enforcement who attempt to keep the peace. The local sheriff, the granddaughter of the mysterious Black Glider, has her work cut out for when a murder of a beloved former hero occurs. Those involved are reluctant to talk and there are hints of something sinister bubbling beneath the surface of this superhero paradise.
Evaluative comments with rating: 3/5 TVs – Better than most of what’s on TV
Gail Simone is one of the better comic book writers in the industry and usually manages to combine wit and humour with strong female characters, Welcome to Tranquility is no exception. Unfortunately, Welcome to Tranquility tries to do a little too much within its confines. “Historical” material is introduced alongside the story’s present-day narrative and rather than enhancing the storytelling, it detracts from it and confuses the reader. Welcome to Tranquility is a fun post-modern take on superheroes (think a more lighthearted Watchmen), but it works best for readers who have a solid handle on superhero comics, but might be a little tired of superhero conventions.
Suggested Audience (age range): 14+

Readers’ advisory notes (appeal factors/readalikes):

Appeal factors: Action-packed, intricately plotted, plot-driven, world-building, funny, suspenseful, offbeat

Readalikes: The Watchmen - Alan Moore, 1963 – Alan Moore, Astro City – Kurt Busiek, Young Heroes in Love – Dan Raspler, America’s Best Comics – Alan Moore, Ex Machina – Brian K. Vaughan

Booktalking hook:

Sheriff Lindo: That harmless old guy? That used to be the most powerful maxi goin'. Had a magic word that turned him from an accountant into a superhero. Only, he had an accident. Forgot the word. Now he reads dictionaries, every single word, all day long, tryin' to find that word again. That one's Hebrew, I think. These people, Collette. They told the Nazis to shove it. Sometimes literally. Don't make them a punchline.

Reason for inclusion: Familiarity with the author’s prior works.
Thomasina Lindo (main character) of Welcome to Tranquility was named Best Female Character in the Glyph Comic Awards
Category: Graphic Novel/Mystery

Rucker Park Setup


Author: Paul Volponi

Bibliographic Info:
Volponi, Paul. (2007). Rucker park setup. New York: Speak.

Descriptive Summary:
Mackey must find the strength and courage to come forward after his friend and basketball teammate, J.R., is stabbed to death. But those qualities aren't so quick to come to the fore, especially given Mackey's role in J.R.'s murder. In basketball, everyone's counting on Mackey to come up big, that's the easy part. The hard part is coming up big when he knows he'll be letting everyone down.

Evaluative comments with rating:
5/5 TVs - TVs are dated, reading isn't - pick up this book!

Volponi's (and Rucker Park Setup's) strength is dialogue. Often when reading YA novels, the dialogue sticks out like a sore thumb and seems dated, that isn't the case with Volponi. His characters speak like kids speak, they think like kids speak and that's what makes his work so realistic. It's also precisely why the stakes in Rucker Park Setup matter, the reader cares about the characters because they're believable. Volponi's writing is deft and difficult, the conclusion of Rucker Park Setup isn't happy, pat, or simplistic, but it is very real and that's why this is book is worth recommending.

Suggested Audience (age range): 12-16 (some strong language and violence)

Readers’ advisory notes:

Appeal factors: Issue-oriented, disturbing, emotionally intense, suspenseful, slang-heavy, moving

Readalikes: Sentences: The Life of MF Grimm - Percy Carey, Snitch - Allison van Diepen, The Outsiders - S.E. Hinton, Bluford High: Blood is Thicker - Paul Langan, Bronx Masquerade - Nikki Grimes

Booktalking hook:
From page 11:

"Stove's got the game ball under his arm and a whistle hanging from his neck. Only J.R.'s not here—because I fucked up so bad. And his killer's standing right there, cool as anything, like he doesn't have to think twice about me giving him up."

Reason for inclusion: Familiarity with the book and author from shelving it

Category:  Urban Fiction/Street Lit/Thriller/Murder/Realistic

Response



Author: Paul Volponi

Bibliographic Info:
Volponi, Paul. (2009). Response. New York: Speak.

Descriptive Summary:

Three high school friends, in need of quick cash, devise a low risk plan to steal a Lexus and pass it off to a local chop shop. The fast cash is alluring to Noah, who is a already a father, and too hard to pass up. Things don't go quite as planned and Noah winds up on the receiving end of a baseball bat from a white attacker. Was Noah a victim of a hate crime? Is Noah ready to be a man and take responsibility for his own actions?

Evaluative comments with rating:
4/5 TVs - Much better than after school special/movie of the week

Volponi's dialogue and experiences with the justice system are his strengths in Response - a quick meaningful read that explores issues of coming of age and racism. Response isn't quite as strong as Rucker Park Setup and it might be because the territory seems slightly well-worn and the ending seems just a little too easy. That's not to say that Volponi isn't lobbing any softballs when it comes to race relations here. Response reads like a modern-day version of Do The Right Thing, but only maybe with a little more realism (if that's possible). Volponi does his best with a complicated issue, it's not his best work, but it's a far sight better than a lot of attempts at understanding the complex nature of hate crimes. A worthy read for anyone with an interest in Urban Fiction.

Suggested Audience (age range):14-18 (some strong language and violence)

Readers’ advisory notes:

Appeal factors:
Issue-oriented, disturbing, emotionally intense, suspenseful, dialogue-rich, reflective

Readalikes: The Skin I'm In - Sharon Flake, The Bully/The Gun - Paul Langan, Monster - Walter Dean Myers, Dark Dude - Oscar Hijuelos, You Don't Even Know Me: Stories and Poems About Boys - Sharon Flake, After Tupac and D Foster - Jacqueline Woodson

Booktalking hook:
To what extent do you think hate crimes occur in Nova Scotia? What about in Halifax?

Reason for inclusion: Familiarity with the author from shelving.

Category: Urban Fiction/Street Lit/Race Relations

Jumped

 
Author: Rita Williams-Garcia

Bibliographic Info:
Williams-Garcia, Rita. (2009). Jumped. New York: Amistad.

Descriptive Summary:
Violence is on the horizon at inner city school when Trina bumps into Dominique on the wrong day at the wrong time. Leticia is unsure whether to get involved and try to stop the violence, or mind her own business and remain a bystander. Rita Williams-Garcia examines the anatomy of violence from three very different and unique perspectives in Jumped.

Evaluative comments with rating:
5/5 TVs - There's nothing like this on TV!

Jumped is great! Finally something produced by adults that realized that bullying doesn't just happen in a vacuum and a bully is something more complex than just a simple aggressor. Williams-Garcia alternates voices and perspectives with Jumped's chapters and in doing so she creates well rounded, fully formed characters that give readers a better sense of how and why violence takes place and how it affects and afflicts our community all.  The blame is shared in Jumped and like any good book, there are no easy answers. Jumped's somewhat disturbing ending is a good jumping off point for discussions about violence, bullying, and what we can do to avoid these incidents and behaviours. It's not easy, but at least Jumped is willing to be realistic about it and start discussion rather than just suggesting that we "unlike" bullying.

Suggested Audience (age range): 12-18 (some mild language and violence)

Readers’ advisory notes:

Appeal factors: Slang-heavy, dialogue-rich, suspenseful, character-driven, issue-oriented, reflective

Readalikes: Give a Boy a Gun - Todd Strasser, Just Another Hero - Sharon Draper,  The Orange Houses - Paul Griffin, Rucker Park Setup - Paul Volponi

Booktalking hook:
From Page 21:
"Like she don't see I'm here and all the space around me is mines so keep your pink ass on that side of the lane. No. She cuts a knife right through my space then turns. And I slam my fist into my other hand because shes's good as jumped and I say, "Her. I'm gonna kick that ass at two forty-five."

Reason for inclusion:
Familiarity with the author – I had come across the book previously when shelving.
  • 2009 National Book Award Finalist
  • ALA Best Book for Young Adults 
Category: Realistic/Award-winning

The Giver



Author:  Lois Lowry

Bibliographic Info:
Lowry, Lois. (1993). The giver.  Ember: New York.

Notes: This is a 2011 reprint of the work

Descriptive Summary:
Jonas lives in a well oiled society where differences fear to tread and where the job you will have for the rest of your life is given to you in the Ceremony of Twelve. When Jonas's name is finally called and he learns that he has been selected to receive a high honor. Jonas soon falls under the tutelage of The Giver to prepare him for the honor. Jonas is to receive the collective memories of the community and in doing so he experience feelings and emotions he had never previously encountered. He also uncovers the reasons for the homogenous society. The Giver and Jonas devise a plan to bring change to the community, but that change can only come about if Jonas leaves everything and everyone he knows behind.

Evaluative comments with rating:

5/5 TVs - a modern classic

Stories like this are always important for young adults, teens, and children. It's a great way for children to learn to question why things are the way they are and how a homogenous life can lead to stagnation. I'm not always big on stories like this simply because the characters usually only exist in order to serve a grander issue (and this novel is no exception), but when the writing is as rich and beautiful as Lowry's; it's easy to overlook. The Giver is a nice "big ideas" book that serves as a modern day parable. It's not bogged down by heavy sci-fi settings and because of that it's accessible to a wide array of readers. The ending isn't pedantic and it's a pleasant surprise that it's open ended. Lowry doesn't dumb anything down for her readers. Lois Lowry creates a nice literary touchstone for a new generation of readers and nurtures a healthy questioning attitude in them.

Suggested Audience (age range): 12-15

Readers’ advisory notes:

Appeal factors: Haunting, serious, compelling, world-building, reflective, strong sense of place

Readalikes: Divergent - Veronica Roth, The Chrysalids - John Wyndham,  Fahrenheit 451 - Ray Bradbury, Gathering Blue - Lois Lowry, Unwind - Neal Shusterman, Matched - Ally Condie

Booktalking hook:
Show clips from movies like the Village and the Hunger Games featuring similar societies that prize people knowing their place and role.

Reason for inclusion: Recommendations by several blogs.

1994 Newberry Medal winner

Category: Controversial/Award-Winning/Science Fiction/Classic